The First Question on the Callback
I asked the room if they'd call the seller back and offer the most they could pay. We'd just run the numbers on a house I was looking to wholesale. Before I gave the seller a price, I wanted to hear his again. If he was close to what I could pay, I'd have a reason to keep going. If there was a big gap, I'd want to know whether it was worth spending more time on the property.
That's a useful thing to settle before you pick up the phone. The most I'd pay depends on what the house could sell for once it's fixed up, what it might cost to do the work, and how much room I need for the wholesale fee. I can make a first pass before I've walked the property, as long as I keep track of what I've assumed. I wanted to be able to explain each number, even if I was the only one looking at the calculation. I started with what I thought the finished house could sell for.
Give the Deal a Resale Number First
The seller had paid $35,000 for the property 20 years earlier. That tells me what it took to buy the place back then. When I'm working out what I can offer, I separate that old purchase price from what the seller is asking today and what I think the house could sell for after repairs. The resale estimate is the figure I can start working on before I call him back.
After-repair value, or ARV, is what I think the property could sell for once the planned work is done. I was looking at comparable properties with similar square footage around $180,000. I used $170,000 for this deal. I wanted some room in case we couldn't sell it for the higher number. When you look at a comparable property, check what the buyer got for the price. If the house was already fixed up, ask what work it would take to give your buyer a house in similar condition. If you can't picture the work that gets you there, that sale may be a weak basis for your estimate. The resale price and the repair scope have to make sense together.
I took 70% of $170,000 and got $119,000. That's a first pass when I screen a possible deal. The other 30% has to leave room for the lender, taxes, insurance, and the cost of holding the house. If the work takes longer than expected, some of those bills keep coming. I'd check them before relying on the screen. Now I need to see how much of that $119,000 would go into the house.
Write Down the Number You Can Use on the Call
The seller described the house as being in good condition. He also said the tenant had been there for 20 years. I told the room, "Good condition means different things to different people." The tenant may be fine living there as it is. I need to know what has been updated and what the next buyer would expect. I'd ask what the owner already repaired and when, then look at the house before deciding whether the work I had in mind would get it close to the comparable properties.
I used $30 a square foot as a starting allowance for cosmetic work on this house. At 1,152 square feet, that came to $34,560, which I rounded to $35,000 for the first pass. That is the allowance used in this example, not a current renovation quote. I'd need to see the property, list the work, and get it priced. If I'm assuming paint and flooring but the walk-through reveals a roof problem, I'd price that added work before relying on the estimate. Keep the original allowance beside the revised scope so you can explain what changed. Check what each quote leaves out, too. A lower price for a smaller scope won't answer the same question.
Here's how the rounded repair allowance and the fee fit into the calculation.
| Step in the calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Assumed after-repair value | $170,000 |
| 70% of assumed after-repair value | $119,000 |
| Subtract estimated repairs, rounded | −$35,000 |
| Amount before the wholesale fee | $84,000 |
| Subtract the wholesale fee in this example | −$10,000 |
| Seller-side ceiling under these assumptions | $74,000 |
I planned to wholesale this one, so I needed room for the investor who'd take the deal and do the work. I'd earn the fee for putting the deal together and bringing it to that investor. I allowed $10,000 for it in this example. If I promised the whole $84,000 to the seller, there'd be nothing left in that figure for the fee. At $74,000, the fee still fits and the repair allowance is still in the math. That's the most this calculation would support on the seller's side. That's the number I'd keep in front of me when I asked for his price.
Decide What the Lead Has Earned
Say the seller asks for $80,000. That's a hypothetical price, and it lands in the gap that matters. It fits under the amount before the fee and comes in $6,000 above what I'd be prepared to pay under my starting assumptions. If I'm comfortable with the estimates and he's firm on price, I can leave it there. If the price is within my ceiling, I have a reason to ask more about the condition and see if I can walk through the house. How much I'd actually offer would depend on what I found.
Change one number at a time and see what happens. Suppose better comps put the finished value $10,000 lower. At 70%, that takes $7,000 off the seller-side number and puts me at $67,000. Start again with my original assumptions, then see what happens if an inspection were to turn up $10,000 more work. That whole cost comes out of what I can pay, leaving $64,000. I changed one estimate in each example. Either change puts that asking price farther out of reach.
On a visit, I'd want to leave knowing what I needed to add to the scope and which parts of the original estimate still held up. I'd price the changed work and recalculate before I discussed a revised offer. If I needed to come back with a lower price, I'd want to be able to tell the seller what I saw and what it would cost to handle. I don't want to make a habit of giving somebody a number and counting on changing it after I get there.
For that hypothetical $80,000 ask to work, I'd need evidence that improves one of the assumptions: a comparable sale supporting a higher finished value, or a lower repair estimate that still delivers the same finished condition. Closing the gap on repairs alone would require a defensible $6,000 reduction. Leaving work off the list could also lower what the house would sell for. If neither estimate changes, I've got my answer. If one does, I can show where the extra room came from before discussing a different number with the seller.
Three Notes Before You Dial
Before I call back, I want three things on the same page: the price question I'm going to ask, the most I could pay with the numbers I've got, and the one thing I'd check before trusting that number. On this deal, I'd want to know what the seller meant by good condition. On yours, the biggest question might be whether the comparable sale is close enough to use.
Ask the price and give the seller time to answer. You can decide then whether there's enough room to go see the house or whether you need better information first. If you've got a property you're working through, bring those notes and questions to the Grab the Map Method live training. Bring the estimate you'd check before you put your number in front of the seller.

