A seller's asking price is useful information. It is not the whole conversation. In this training, Johnoson Crutchfield explains why his team separates learning about the property from presenting an offer.
The first conversation gives you something to investigate. The next gives you a chance to return with numbers you can explain. You do not have to calculate an offer while a seller waits on the phone.
First, understand what the seller wants to change
Ask what the owner wants to do, what timing matters and what they expect from a sale. Check the property condition and occupancy. An owner who wants to stop managing a rental may need a different conversation from someone comparing offers for a vacant house.
John opens with a historical property he had under contract. The listing, an appraisal, a tenant in place and the owner's ongoing expenses all raised questions to check. That example was a work in progress in the recording, not evidence of a completed sale or a return you can repeat.
A long listing period does not prove distress. A tenant does not automatically make a property worth less. Find out what applies to this property before choosing a strategy.
Give each important claim a supporting record
| What you hear | What to review | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| The property appraised higher | Appraisal date, comparable sales and current condition | A past valuation is not a guaranteed resale price |
| The tenant pays a stated rent | Lease, collections and ongoing expenses | Scheduled rent alone does not establish cash flow |
| The repairs are finished | Scope of work, available records and property inspection | Photos can miss unfinished work |
| The owner wants to be done | Timing, responsibilities and the proposed agreement | Different terms can create different obligations |
Use the pause between conversations to fill those gaps. John encourages investors to bring questions to people with relevant experience. That can help you spot an assumption you missed; it does not replace inspecting the property or obtaining the right professional review.
Calculate a limit you can defend
John demonstrates a screening calculation using 70% of after-repair value, less estimated repairs and a wholesale fee. He also discusses how conditions affect the opportunities his team sees. Treat the formula as part of that training, not a universal buying rule.
The difference between 70% and 100% is not a guaranteed 30% profit. Financing, holding costs, sale costs, repairs and a lower eventual value can change the result. Build those costs into your analysis and test what happens if the project takes longer.
Know your upper limit before discussing a counteroffer. If financing terms are involved, review the payment obligations, risks and documents separately. Do not let an appealing monthly payment take the place of understanding the agreement.
If an existing loan is involved, ask who remains responsible for it. Fannie Mae explains the distinction between assuming a mortgage and obtaining a release of liability. Those questions need answers before an agreement, not after it.
Return with an offer and a clear next step
- Recap the facts. Confirm the seller's goals and correct any misunderstandings.
- Explain the offer. Describe the price, timing and terms you can actually support.
- Allow a decision. Make time for questions and review; do not invent a partner or deadline to force agreement.
- Record the outcome. Document the agreed action, or ask whether and when further contact would be welcome.
Two conversations are a useful structure, not a requirement to rush. More discussion may be necessary. A seller may decline, and that decision deserves respect. Follow-up works best when both sides understand the next step.
Before making that next offer, work through the investment property analysis guide. A seller's needs help shape the conversation. Verified numbers determine what you can offer.



